Value Engineering vs Build-to-Print Fabrication
The choice between value engineering and build-to-print fabrication affects cost, quality, and performance. Here's how they compare.
Book a Solution CallQuick Answer
Value engineering reviews a design for manufacturability, weight, cost, and constructability, then builds the improved version. Build-to-print fabrication builds exactly what the drawings specify, without review or improvement. Value engineering produces a better assembly; build-to-print produces exactly what was drawn. RoXteel's Product Design team value engineers before manufacturing.
Key Differences
Value engineering is an active process, the manufacturer reviews the design, identifies improvements, and produces an optimized version. Build-to-print is a passive process, the manufacturer builds exactly what's drawn, regardless of whether the design is optimal. Value engineering requires a Product Design function; build-to-print requires only fabrication capability.
Side-by-Side Comparison
Value Engineering (RoXteel Approach)
- •Product Design reviews the design before manufacturing
- •Identifies manufacturability improvements
- •Reduces weight and part count
- •Improves constructability and installation
- •Optimizes for cost, shipping, and field labor
- •Produces a better assembly than the original
- •Proven by the plenum story, over-engineered design reengineered
- •4-step process: Call, Review, Collaborate, Proposal
Build-to-Print Fabrication (Conventional)
- •Builds exactly what the drawings specify
- •No design review or improvement
- •No weight or cost optimization
- •No constructability analysis
- •Accepts the design as-is, including inefficiencies
- •Requires only fabrication capability
- •Suitable when the design is already optimized
Advantages & Tradeoffs
Value engineering's advantage is a better product, lighter, cheaper, simpler, faster to install. Build-to-print's advantage is simplicity, no design review process, just fabrication. But for most designs, there are improvement opportunities that value engineering can capture, resulting in lower total project cost.
When Each Approach Makes Sense
Value engineering makes sense for any project where the design may not be fully optimized, which is most projects. Build-to-print may make sense when the design is already fully optimized by an experienced engineer, or when the customer explicitly wants no changes to their design. For most industrial steel assemblies, value engineering produces a better outcome.
Where RoXteel Fits
RoXteel's Product Design team value engineers every assembly before manufacturing. The team reviews for manufacturability, weight, cost, and constructability, then builds the improved version. This is the same approach that took an over-engineered plenum system and reengineered it into the standardized Modular Plenum System.
Built in Arizona. Supporting Projects Nationwide.
Manufactured at the All Things Metal campus in Wittmann, Arizona, with project support across all 50 states.
Book a Solution Call
Bring us the problem. Product Design reviews your assembly for manufacturability, weight, cost, and constructability, then builds it.
