RoXteel Industrial, An All Things Metal Brand
Comparison & Decision

Shop Assembly vs Field Assembly

The choice between shop assembly and field assembly affects quality, schedule, and cost. Here's how they compare.

Book a Solution Call

Quick Answer

Shop assembly builds steel structures in a controlled environment, weather-independent, precision-controlled, and QC-documented. Field assembly builds steel on site, subject to weather, site conditions, and variable labor quality. Shop assembly produces higher quality in less time; field assembly is more flexible but less controlled.

Key Differences

Shop assembly happens indoors, flat tables, overhead cranes, certified welders, and documented QC. Field assembly happens outdoors, subject to weather, site congestion, and variable conditions. Shop assembly shifts complexity upstream; field assembly manages it on site. The fundamental difference is environment, controlled vs variable.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Shop Assembly (RoXteel Approach)

  • •Controlled indoor environment
  • •Weather-independent production
  • •Flat tables, overhead cranes, certified welders
  • •Documented QC on every weld and dimension
  • •Precision fabrication, tight tolerances
  • •Faster production, no weather delays
  • •Higher quality, controlled conditions
  • •Assemblies arrive ready to install

Field Assembly (Conventional)

  • •Built on site, outdoors, variable conditions
  • •Subject to weather delays
  • •Variable labor quality and supervision
  • •More rework and field engineering
  • •More site congestion and material handling
  • •Looser tolerances, field conditions
  • •Longer assembly time
  • •More coordination between trades

Advantages & Tradeoffs

Shop assembly's advantages are quality, speed, and predictability. Field assembly's advantage is flexibility, it can be adapted to any site condition. But for most industrial steel assemblies, the quality and schedule benefits of shop assembly far outweigh the flexibility of field assembly.

When Each Approach Makes Sense

Shop assembly makes sense for any assembly that can be transported to the site, which is most assemblies when designed with shipping in mind. Field assembly may be necessary for very large structures that can't be shipped, or for site-specific modifications. But even large structures can often be shop-assembled in modules and bolted together on site.

Where RoXteel Fits

RoXteel assembles steel in a controlled shop environment on a 55-acre campus. Product Design designs every assembly for shop fabrication and efficient field installation. The Modular Plenum System demonstrates the approach, shop-assembled 20-foot sections that bolt together on site in approximately 10× less time than field-built alternatives.

Built in Arizona. Supporting Projects Nationwide.

Manufactured at the All Things Metal campus in Wittmann, Arizona, with project support across all 50 states.

55
Acre All Things Metal campus
~60K
Sq ft facility under construction
50
States with project support
AZ
Manufacturing base, Wittmann

Book a Solution Call

Bring us the problem. Product Design reviews your assembly for manufacturability, weight, cost, and constructability, then builds it.

Book a Solution Call